Friday, January 16, 2009

Chapter 9

Why does Grendel find the Priest's conversation "strange?" Why does the younger priest believe that Ork's "vision proves there is hope for us all"!In Chapter 8, the sign is Scorpio.In Chapter 9, the sign is Sagittarius represented by the Archer. Please look up both signs and explain why Gardner might have used these signs as the symbols for each chapter.

SIGNS: SAGITTARIUS AND SCORPIO

The zodiacal constellation Sagittarius represents the centaur Chiron. Most of the centaurs were regarded in myth as bestial--they were, after all, half horse. However, the ancient Greeks had a great deal of respect for the horse, and so were reluctant to make the centaurs entirely bad. In fact, Chiron was renowned for his gentleness. He was an excellent archer, musician, and physician, and tutored the likes of Achilles, Jason, and Hercules.
Chiron, however, was accidentally shot and wounded by Hercules. The arrow, which had been dipped in the poison of the Lernaean
Hydra, inflicted great suffering on Chiron--so great, in fact, that even the talented physician could not cure himself. In agony, but as an immortal unable to find release in death, Chiron instead offered himself as a substitute for Prometheus. The gods had punished Prometheus for giving fire to man by chaining him to a rock. Each day an eagle would devour his liver, and each night it would grow back. Jupiter, however, had at the request of Hercules agreed to release Prometheus if a suitable substitute could be found. Chiron gave up his immortality and went to Tartarus in place of Prometheus; in recognition of his goodness, Jupiter placed him in the stars (Pasachoff, 139).
From the northern hemisphere, Sagittarius may be seen only in the summer, lying low in the south. The Milky Way runs through Sagittarius.

Scorpius is a zodiacal constellation. The scorpion is generally believed to be responsible for the death of the great hunter Orion. According to some myths, the scorpion stung Orion in response to his boast that he could defeat any beast; according to others, it was sent by Apollo, who was concerned for his sister Diana's continued chastity.
In either case, Scorpius was placed in the opposite side of the sky from Orion so as to avoid any further conflict. It is to the southeast of
Libra, and is marked by the bright red star Antares. (Antares is Greek for "Rival of Ares," the Greek war-god. The star is so named because of of its brightness and color, which are approximately the same as of the planet Mars. Mars, of course, is the Roman name for Ares.)
The sign of "Scorpio" is used in Chapter 8 since the sign was born from the conflict with Orion. This is representative of the conflict between Grendel and the Scyldings. The sign of "Sagittarius" is used in Chapter 9 since there are references to "bows" and "arrows." Hrothgar's "bowmen" are described in the beginning of the chapter. Sagittarius symbolizes war and the death that comes through war.
"I watch one of Hrothgar's bowmen (Sagittarius references) puruse a hart" (126). "And then, incredibly, through the pale, strange light the man's hand moves- click click click click- toward the bow, and grasps it, and draws it down, away from the shoulder and around in front (click click) and transfers the bow to the slowly moving second hand, and the first hand goes back up and (click) over the shoulder and returns with an arrow, threads the bow" (127).
Grendel finds the conversation with the priest named "Ork" unusual. This is because Ork mistakes Grendel for being a god:
The chief of the priests had previously wailed, "Ghostly destroyer, defend the people of Scyld and kill their enemy, the terrible world-rim-walker!" (127)
"There is no conviction in the old priests' songs; there is only showmanship. No one in the kingdom is convinced that the gods have life in them. The weak observe the rituals- take their hats off, put them on again, raise their arms, lower their arms, moan, intone, press their palms together- but no one harbors unreasonable expectations. The will to power resides among the stalactites of the heart" (128).
Ork, the blind eldest and wisest of the priests, mistakes Grendel for being the king of the gods. He says, "The King of the Gods is the ultimate limitation and His existence is the ultimate irrationality" (131). "For no reason can be given for just that limitation which it stands in His nature to impose. The King of the Gods is not concrete, but He is the ground for concrete actuality. No reason can be given for the nature of God, because that nature is the ground of rationality" (131).
Grendel is surprised after Ork has been moved to tears: "I [Grendel] raise my fingers to my mouth, baffled" (132).
Grendel is further surprised when Ork begins violently shaking and thinks that perhaps he is just cold. Instead "he [Ork] stretches out his arms toward the sky, huge-knuckled fingers gnarled and twisted as if to frighten me. 'O the ultimate evil, such as hatred, or suffering, or death!' The ultimate evil is that Time is perpetual perishing, and being actual involves elimination. The nature of evil may be epitomized, therefore, in two simple but horrible and holy propositions: 'Things fade' and 'Alternatives exclude'" (133).
The younger priest believes that Ork's "vision proves there is hope for us all." After hearing of Ork's vision of "God" he says, "A vision of the Destroyer! Of course, of course! Before we know it, you'll be kissing girls! Can't you grasp it, brothers? Both blood and sperm are explosive, irregular, feeding-pitched, messy- and inexplicably fascinating! They transcend! They leap the gap! O blessed Ork! I believe your vision prove there is hope for us all!" (136).
The youngest priest is hopeful about Ork's vision, since Ork's thought process had always been mainly rational and he could never believe anything irrational. Therefore, Ork's vision of Grendel represents a step for him outside of his normal thought process and so the priest takes it as a good sign. However, Ork does not necessarily believe that the youngest priest actually buys into his vision.

Chapter 8

In what ways does the character of Red Horse embody the political concept of Machiavellianism? If you have not been exposed to Machiavelli - learn about him today!Red Horse also has some Anarchist tendencies - can you give me an example?Also, what does Hrothgar have to do with Plato's Republic?Finally, Grendel says at the end of the chapter, "I made him what he is." In what ways does that connect to page 91 where Grendel exclaims, "My enemies define themselves on me?"Can you think of a person that might be uttering this phrase at this very moment?

MACHIAVELLIANISM: (definitions)
the political doctrine of Machiavelli: any means (however unscrupulous) can be used by a ruler in order to create and maintain his autocratic ...wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn
Machiavellianism is the term that some social and personality psychologists use to describe a person's tendency to deceive and manipulate others for personal gain. The concept is named after Renaissance diplomat and writer Niccolò Machiavelli, who wrote Il Principe (The Prince). ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machiavellianism
A measure of the degree to which people are pragmatic, maintain emotional distance, and believe that end justifies means.
www.crfonline.org/orc/glossary/m.html
A personality dimension characterised by the manipulation of others.
www.tabmd.com/md/m-4.htm

There is a parallel that exists between Grendel’s relationship with the dragon and the Red Horse’s relationship with the character Hrothulf. The dragon had served as a philosophical teacher to Grendel, and the Red Horse serves as a teacher to Hrothulf, as well.

“If the Revolution comes to grief, it will be you and those you lead have become alarmed at your own brutality” (117). “The total ruin of institutions and morals is an act of creation. A religious act. Murder and mayhem are the life and soul of revolution. I imagine you won’t laugh when I tell you that. There are plenty of fools who would” (118).

Red Horse explains to Hrothulf that he must find a way to frame his revolution, which has to be violently executed. Machiavellian concepts are shown through his descriptions of government as a branch that only protects the powerful and ignores the weak.

Allusion to Plato's Republic:
"Hrothgar, keen of mind, is out of schemes. No fault of his. There are no schemes left. And so he waits like a man chained in a cave, staring at the entrance or, sometimes, gazing with sad, absent-minded eyes at Wealtheow, chained beside him" (122).

ANARCHIST (plural anarchists)
One who believes in or advocates the absence of
government in all forms (compare anarchism), especially one who works toward the realization of such.
One who disregards
laws and social norms as a form of rebellion against authority.
By extension from previous sense, one who
promotes chaos and lawlessness; a nihilist or terrorist.
One who resents outside control or influence on his or her life, in particular a government, and therefore desires the absence of political control.

The Red Horse's anarchist tendencies are shown through his rejection of governmental ideas. "The state is an organization of violence, a monopoly in what it is pleased to call legitimate violence. Revolution, my dear prince, is not the substitution of immoral or moral, or of illegitimate or legitimate violence; it is simply the pitting of power against power, where the issue of freedom for the winners and enslavement of the rest" (119). "But I'm a simple man, you see," he said, "and that's exactly what I do. All systems are evil. All governments are evil. Not just a trifle evil. Monstrously evil." "Though he smiled, he was shaking, only half controlling it. 'If you want me to help you destroy a government, I'm here to serve. But as for Universal Justice-'" (120).

"I made him what he is" reflects back to the quote "My enemies define themselves on me." This means that people are shaped by opposition. Without an external struggle, people have to reason to fight or attack. Therefore, Grendel serves as a conflict that the Scyldings must overcome. Without Grendel, there can be no heroes among the Scyldings to take him down. Grendel causes the Scyldings many problems and deaths, but he is an essential part of their society.

Chapter 6 & 7

Considering what happens to both Grendel and Unferth in Chapter 6, why do you think the Chapter begins with the line: "Nothing was changed, everything was changed." Why do you think Skepticism defines this chapter?In Chapter 7, Grendel states that "My enemies define themselves (as the dragon said) on me." Considering what we have studied about Monsters and 'The Other', do you agree with Grendel? In your opinion, does Wealtheow represent a Christ figure? Provide specific examples to support your claims. Where is the sign of Libra found in Chapter 7?

Previously in Chapter 5 Grendel had encountered the dragon. In Chapter 6 Grendel realizes that the dragon has put a charm on him, since when the men attack him they do not injure him. After Grendel learns that he cannot be attacked, he laughs about it. "I laughed. It was outrageous: they came, they fell, howling insanity about brothers, fathers, glorious Hrothgar, and God" (81). "Nothing was changed, everything was changed" describes how seemingly nothing unusual had happened to Grendel after he visited the dragon. In Chapter 5 the dragon had tried to reach Grendel through in depth conversations, but Grendel's immaturity prevents him from understanding the dragon's wisdom. However, Grendel soon comes to the realization that he no longer has to fight off men, but is instead completely omnipotent. His quest for power over the men continues as he keeps the blood bath going by taking lives of countless men. Grendel is happy with his new found power, but also angered after he hears the Shaper's song: (pg. 77) "I no longer remember exactly what he sang. I know only that it had a strange effect on me: it no longer filled me with doubt and distress, loneliness, shame. It enraged me. It was their confidence, maybe- their blissful, swinish ignorance, their bumptious self-satisfaction, and, worst of all, their hope." This reveals Grendel's distress and how he still feels alone in the world. Power is not enough because he does not have anyone else. His mother has nearly abandoned him by not protecting him and just sits in the cave. Instead Grendel has to fight on his own like a bully preying on smaller children. Skepticism defines Chapter 6 because Grendel is skeptical about the philosophies that the dragon has told him in Chapter 5: "What god? Where? Life-force, you mean? The principle of process? God as the history of chance?...My advice to you, my violent friend, is to seek out gold and sit on it" (74). During Chapter 6, Grendel is still skeptical about what the dragon has told him, but he still think about it. He is confused on account of his new power, but he is also saddened because he know that he will always be at war with men. "My enemies define themselves (as the dragon said) on me." I agree with Grendel's statement from Chapter 7, since without Grendel the men that attacked him would not be "heros." Unferth's purpose in attacking Grendel was to go down in songs and myths as a hero. If Grendel was not the enemy to defeat, then the Scyldings would have no huge conflict. Therefore Grendel is as much a part of them as they are a part of him. Grendel likes to pick the men off one by one and would not have that instant gratification if they were not there. Grendel only is a "monster" because the men around him think that he is. If Grendel was all alone then he would not be a "monster." Society deems monsters; people create monsters. Grendel alone would not be a monster. Weatheow is portrayed in a god like manner in Chapter 7. "As if for my benefit, as if in vicious scorn of me, children came from the meadhall and ran down to her, weeping, to snatch to her hands and dress" (100). This is a biblical allusion to Jesus who would have children run up to him and touch his hands and feet. "She did not look at them, merely touched their heads. 'Be still,' she said- hardly more than a whisper, but it carried across the crowd. They were still, as if her voice were magic" (101). "I could see myself leaping from my high tree and running on all fours through the crowd to her, howling, whimpering, throwing myself down, drooling and groveling at her small, fur-booted feet. 'Mercy!' I would howl" (101). Grendel is helpless in the presense of a person of god like status. "She would gladly have given her life to end my suffering - horrible, humpbacked, carp-tootled creature, eyes on fire with useless, mindless love" (102). The sign of "Libra" is symbolized by the scales. The scales are also a symbol of justice. Libra's symbol is the only symbol in the zodiac that is inanimate (it is not represented by an animal or person).

Plan for the Final Four Chapters of Grendel

Chapter 12:

Throughout the chapter there are allusions to water and pisces: "feeling the dark power moving in me like an ocean current, some monster inside me, deep sea wonder (173). "Shapes vague as lurking seaweed surround us" (170).

Color imagery: green dust, purple dust, gold

Grendel moves "voluntarily" to his death as he walks toward the edge of the cliff.

"I seem to desire my fall, and though I fight it with all my will I know in advance that I can't win" (173).

Grendel had just sang the song: "The wall will fall to the wind as the windy hill will fall, and all things thought in former times: Nothing made remains, nor man remembers. And these towns shall be called the shining towns!" (172). This song foreshadows Grendel's plunge off of the cliff. In the end Grendel becomes like the Shaper as he predicts what is to come. Like the Shaper, Grendel eventually dies.

"I do not listen. I am sick at heart. I have been betrayed before by talk like that" (170).

"'Poor Grendel's had an accident,' I whisper. 'So may you all'" (174). After Grendel becomes wise and has predicted the future as a "Shaper," he dies. He refers to his entanglement with Beowulf as an "accident," since he had slipped on blood when Beowulf grabbed hold of his arm. In the end as Grendel is about to walk off the cliff, he calls it an "accident."

PISCES: "As you see it is, while the seeing lasts, dark nighmare-history, time-as-coffin; but where the water was rigid there will be fish, and men will survive on their flesh till spring." Biblical reference: fish. Beowulf is symbolically the "fish."

Diction: illusion, dream, chance, fire, darkness, tricks, accident

"The world is my bone cave, I shall not want..." Beowulf says this directly to Grendel. As opposed to Grendel, Beowulf does not need a cave sanctuary to hide out in for protection. Instead the world is Beowulf's "bone cave."

"Art is a lie that tells a truth." Art is the depiction of reality but is not in fact reality. However, what one gets out of a piece of art can speak loudly. Powerful artwork depicting significant historical events has moved people to discover "truth."